Data protection
Someone asked you to delete their data. When you must, and when you can't
You must delete personal data when one of the GDPR's grounds applies and no exception does, and you have one month to answer. Records Irish law tells you to keep stay, and you say so in the reply.
By FourWindsCurrent as at 5 minute read6 sources
The short answer
An erasure request has to be answered, but it doesn't always end in deletion. Article 17 of the GDPR gives a person the right to have their data erased when one of six grounds applies, and it lists the cases where you keep the data anyway.
Article 12(3) gives you one month from receipt to act on the request or tell the person why you won't. Where requests are complex or numerous, you can extend by two further months, as long as you tell the person within the first month and give your reasons. The way to count the month is the same as for an access request, set out in our access request guide.
When you have to delete
The Data Protection Commission lists the grounds in plain terms. You must erase the data without undue delay where:
- 1it's no longer needed for the purpose you collected it for;
- 2the person withdraws consent and you have no other lawful basis;
- 3the person objects and you have no overriding legitimate grounds to continue;
- 4the person objects to direct marketing, which always wins;
- 5the data was processed unlawfully;
- 6Irish or EU law requires the erasure;
- 7it was collected from a child through an online service.
When you keep it, and say why
Article 17(3) sets out the exceptions. For a professional firm two of them matter most: keeping data to comply with a legal obligation, and keeping it to establish, exercise or defend legal claims. The others cover freedom of expression, public health, and archiving and research in the public interest.
Irish law sets several of those legal obligations in years. A company keeps its accounting records for at least six years after the end of the financial year they relate to (Companies Act 2014, section 285). Tax records are kept for six years after the transactions they record (Taxes Consolidation Act 1997, section 886). A designated person under the anti-money laundering Act, which includes an accountant or a solicitor, keeps customer due diligence records for at least five years after the last service to that customer (section 55 of the 2010 Act).
The DPC also points to section 60 of the Data Protection Act 2018, which restricts the right where that's necessary for important objectives of public interest, and section 43, which balances it against freedom of expression.
Delete what you can, keep what you must
An exception covers the records the law names, for as long as it names. Marketing lists, old enquiries and copies in shared folders usually fall outside it and can go now.
An accountancy practice, worked through
Take a twelve-person accountancy practice. A former client who left eighteen months ago emails to ask that everything held on them be deleted.
The practice finds four kinds of record: the client's newsletter subscription, old email threads with general queries, the identity documents taken when it onboarded them, and the working papers behind the returns it filed.
The newsletter entry goes at once, because an objection to direct marketing always succeeds. General email threads with no further purpose go too. The identity documents stay, because section 55 of the anti-money laundering Act requires them for at least five years after the last service. The working papers stay while they're needed to defend a claim about the advice given.
The reply says what was deleted, what was kept, the law behind each kept item, and when it will be deleted. It also tells the client they can complain to the DPC, which Article 12(4) requires whenever you don't act on a request.
What makes this quick next time
Requests take longest when nobody knows where a person's data lives. A record of processing that lists each system and its retention period turns the search into a checklist, and it's the record the DPC expects you to keep anyway.
Keep a short note of every request: the date it arrived, what you searched, what you deleted and kept, and the date you replied. Article 5(2) makes you responsible for showing you complied, and that note is how you show it. Eurus keeps each check result it records with a SHA-256 fingerprint chained to the one before, so anyone holding an export can confirm at eurus.ie/verify that nothing was changed afterwards.
Questions
- Is the right to be forgotten the same as the right to erasure?
- Yes. The GDPR uses both names in the heading of Article 17, and the DPC calls it the right to erasure, also known as the right to be forgotten.
- Can we charge a fee or refuse an erasure request?
- Usually not. Article 12(5) makes the first response free. You can refuse, or charge a reasonable fee, only where a request is manifestly unfounded or excessive, and you have to be able to show it was.
- Do we have to delete data from backups too?
- Article 17 has no exception for backups. Where a backup can't be edited, record that the data will expire with it, and make sure it isn't restored into live systems in the meantime.
- Can we keep a former client's file in case they sue?
- Yes, where it's needed for the establishment, exercise or defence of legal claims (Article 17(3)(e)). Keep only what that purpose needs, and set a date to review it.
Sources
- 1.General Data Protection Regulation, Articles 5, 12, 17 and 19 · EUR-Lex
- 2.The right to erasure (Articles 17 and 19 of the GDPR) · Data Protection Commission
- 3.Companies Act 2014, section 285 · Irish Statute Book
- 4.Taxes Consolidation Act 1997, section 886 · Irish Statute Book
- 5.Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010, section 55 · Irish Statute Book
- 6.Data Protection Act 2018, section 60 · Irish Statute Book
See where you stand, in Eurus
Connect your systems once, and Eurus does the talking. It works out which laws apply, finds your AI tools, suppliers and people, and keeps the proof itself. If there is a gap you can't close yourself, FourWinds reviews it and sends a fixed quote.
Try Eurus liveWho wrote this
FourWinds · Compliance experts, and the makers of Eurus
FourWinds writes and maintains the legal explainers on this site, and does the compliance work behind them. Every date and article number here is checked against the legislation itself before it is published, and each article shows the date it was last checked.
Questions and corrections go to support@fourwinds.ie.
More about how we work →Read next
- GDPRA subject access request has arrived. What you owe, and by when
- Compliance deadlinesThe legal clocks that can start running against an Irish business, and what starts each one
- GDPRA record of processing for a small Irish business: what goes in it, and whether you need one
Written on 14 November 2026; it describes the law as FourWinds read it on that date. How we check the law.